MSA 用 ANOVA 和xbar怎么差这么大

各位大神:
闲话少讲，直接上MINTAB RUN 出来结果
选ANOVA，GRR%=20%多
而XBAR, GRR%=有9.%多
哪个地方有问题啊？数据完全一样啊， 急死了
Gage R&R Study - ANOVA Method
 
Two-Way ANOVA Table With Interaction

Source           DF         SS         MS        F      P
part              9  0.0131378  0.0014598  97.7190  0.000
operator          2  0.0000422  0.0000211   1.4132  0.269
part * operator  18  0.0002689  0.0000149   2.2407  0.010
Repeatability    60  0.0004000  0.0000067
Total            89  0.0138489


Alpha to remove interaction term = 0.25

 
Gage R&R

                              %Contribution
Source               VarComp   (of VarComp)
Total Gage R&R     0.0000096           5.66
  Repeatability    0.0000067           3.92
  Reproducibility  0.0000030           1.74
    operator       0.0000002           0.12
    operator*part  0.0000028           1.62
Part-To-Part       0.0001605          94.34
Total Variation    0.0001702         100.00


Process tolerance = 0.2


                                Study Var  %Study Var  %Tolerance
Source             StdDev (SD)   (6 * SD)       (%SV)  (SV/Toler)
Total Gage R&R       0.0031032  0.0186190       23.79        9.31
  Repeatability      0.0025820  0.0154919       19.79        7.75
  Reproducibility    0.0017213  0.0103280       13.20        5.16
    operator         0.0004536  0.0027217        3.48        1.36
    operator*part    0.0016605  0.0099629       12.73        4.98
Part-To-Part         0.0126702  0.0760214       97.13       38.01
Total Variation      0.0130447  0.0782683      100.00       39.13


Number of Distinct Categories = 5

 
Gage R&R for 9.7 New

 
Gage R&R Study - XBar/R Method

                              %Contribution
Source               VarComp   (of VarComp)
Total Gage R&R     0.0000021           0.88
  Repeatability    0.0000014           0.59
  Reproducibility  0.0000007           0.30
Part-To-Part       0.0002365          99.12
Total Variation    0.0002386         100.00


Process tolerance = 0.2


                                Study Var  %Study Var  %Tolerance
Source             StdDev (SD)   (6 * SD)       (%SV)  (SV/Toler)
Total Gage R&R       0.0014526  0.0087153        9.40        4.36
  Repeatability      0.0011816  0.0070898        7.65        3.54
  Reproducibility    0.0008448  0.0050687        5.47        2.53
Part-To-Part         0.0153785  0.0922708       99.56       46.14
Total Variation      0.0154469  0.0926814      100.00       46.34


Number of Distinct Categories = 14

 
Gage R&R for 9.7 New

Raw data